The silent shout of rural youth: Public institutions have failed to listen again*
From: Mrs. Alba Tema
Alba Tema is a young professional in the field of sustainable development of rural areas. She works as Project Officer and Researcher at the Albanian Network for Rural Development and at the same time is the National Coordinator of the Rural Youth Hub Albania.
CCIS YOUTH OBSERVERS
January 10, 2025
For over 30 years, rural youth in Albania have been migrating to urban areas or abroad, in search of better opportunities. According to the Institute of Statistics of Albania, between 2014 and 2023, around 189,734 young people aged 15-35 emigrated, approximately 54% of the country’s total emigrants in this period. Albania is considered a hotspot for youth migration, which has drawn international attention to the phenomenon of brain drain. While migration is a normal process, in Albania, especially in rural areas, it has turned into a persistent exodus that threatens the sustainability of local communities.
Why are rural youth leaving?
The decision to leave often comes from a combination of economic and social factors. Many rural youths seek better living conditions and more stable employment opportunities. In a social cooperative in Cremona, Italy, three Albanian minors from northern rural areas explain their reasons for leaving: “When I turn 18 years old, I will start working… probably in agriculture or maybe in construction. However, I will not pursue any further education. I need to support my family. They depend on me.” Another youngster from Fushe-Kruje, who moved to Cremona years ago, reflected, “Honestly, I don’t plan to return to Albania. I get paid well, and they treat me well here. I don’t think I can build my life in Albania anymore.”
The lack of highs schools near villages and public transportation, as well as low-quality education are other key factors driving youth away from their communities. A youngster in central Albania shared, “I left to study in Tirana 16 years ago. My sister moved from our village when she was 14 years old. This year, my little brother had to leave for a better education. It’s difficult for us to get back to our village; only our parents are staying there.”
But deeper than these socio-economic challenges, young people, especially rural youth often feel unheard, unvalued, and underrepresented. A 19-year-old girl from Hajmel, Shkoder, says, “I have been in Austria and Germany for some months. I am planning to move there. I study informatics, here it’s considered as a work for males. On the other hand, you can work and not be paid well at all. I mean in Shkoder because I haven’t tried it in Tirana.”
The pervasive nature of migration sometimes feels like a societal illness. When I first moved to my new neighborhood in the peripheral part of Tirana, the first thing I noticed was the large houses. However, as days passed, I found myself less surprised by the big buildings and more impressed by the silence around the neighborhood. Conversations with residents revealed more about the tendence of youth to migrate, even though being near to the capital city and have access to services. A woman who runs a small market shared, “I was talking with my son. He is 19 years old and has moved to London. We have our house, this small market… we have everything, but there is better for him. He left like all his friends.”
Rural youth exclusion from youth and rural development policies
The needs of rural youth have been overlooked in national youth policies for a long time. Albania’s National Youth Strategy (2022-2029) outlines a broad framework for youth inclusion, focusing on employment, education, and participation in decision-making. However, it barely addresses the specific needs of rural youth. The strategy mentions rural youth only when it refers to the European Union Youth Strategy (2019-2027), but it doesn’t include any measure that addresses the specific needs of rural youth. On the contrary, the EU Youth Strategy dedicates to rural youth its 6th goal which aims at creating conditions for rural youth to fulfill their potential, by improving infrastructure, offering high-quality jobs, and encouraging rural youth participation in decision-making. Yet, Albania’s National Youth Strategy lacks concrete measures aimed at empowering rural youth.
The Strategy for Agriculture, Rural Development, and Fisheries (SARDF) emphasizes the importance of supporting young farmers. However, while it has proposed some measures aimed at youth in rural areas, these efforts have been insufficient. The SARDF action plan recommended a new initiative for young farmers within the national budget, intended for implementation in 2022-2023. Unfortunately, this scheme has not yet been developed, and rural youth have received minimal support. In contrast, the EU’s Common Agricultural Policy has introduced strategies such as the Complementary Income Support for Young Farmers (CISYF) and other support mechanisms to encourage young farmers in investing in rural areas.
The continuous migration of rural youth in Albania emphasize the failure of public institutions to address their unique needs and aspirations. As they continue leaving in silence their homes in search of a better future, the sustainability of local communities is threatened. It is urgent for policymakers to prioritize the inclusion of rural youth in national development strategies, ensuring that their voices are heard and their potential is fulfilled. Only through comprehensive support and engagement we can reduce migration and encourage rural youth to contribute to the sustainable development of Albania.
_________________________
*This article is produced in the framework of the ERASMUS-YOUTH-2023-CB: A cross regional predictive model for youth policy shaping – Youth Observers. Funded by the European Union. Views and opinions expressed are however those of the author(s) only and do not necessarily reflect those of the European Union or European Education and Culture Executive Agency. Neither the European Union nor the granting authority can be held responsible for them.